The choreography of Beyoncé's "Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It)", released in 2008, is one of the most imitated dances of the century. It was created by Frank Gatson Jr. and JaQuel Knight with Beyoncé, and it is openly based on "Mexican Breakfast", a routine by the Broadway choreographer Bob Fosse, danced by Gwen Verdon and two other dancers on The Ed Sullivan Show in 1969. The story is a good lesson in how choreography travels, and in why heels dancers still study Fosse.

The video

The "Single Ladies" video is simple: three women in black leotards and heels, a white background, one continuous routine in black and white. What made it unforgettable was the choreography, full of sharp hip and head isolations, hand flicks and the famous gesture of showing the ring finger.

JaQuel Knight was 19 when he worked on it with Gatson, Beyoncé's long-time choreographer and creative director. Gatson told Marie Claire it took about a month and a half of work for the dance to look flawless.

"Mexican Breakfast"

Gatson has never hidden the source. He told Marie Claire that the dance was based on a number from The Ed Sullivan Show in 1969, and that he and Beyoncé wanted to modernise it. Beyoncé herself said in 2008 that she had seen the clip on YouTube.

The routine is "Mexican Breakfast", created by Fosse for Verdon, his wife and muse, to perform with two dancers in June 1969. Side by side, the resemblance is clear: the formation of three, the attitude, many of the small hip and hand accents. The "Single Ladies" team added new steps, a faster tempo and a very different energy.

Fosse's style

Bob Fosse shaped Broadway and Hollywood jazz from the 1950s to the 1980s, with shows and films such as Damn Yankees, Sweet Charity, Cabaret and Chicago. His style is instantly recognisable: turned-in knees, rolled shoulders, isolations of the hips, hands and head, hats and gloves, and dramatic stillness.

Gwen Verdon was central to it. Their daughter, Nicole Fosse, has said Verdon understood his intentions so well she could do what he imagined before he explained it. In 2024, NPR reported that Hubbard Street Dance Chicago had added "Sweet Gwen Suite", which includes a reconstruction of "Mexican Breakfast", to its repertoire, with permission from the Fosse/Verdon estate.

Inspiration or copying?

The case is often cited in debates about choreography and copyright. Gatson's position is that the team acknowledged the reference and transformed it. Others point out that Fosse's estate controls how his works are staged, and that the most famous moves of "Single Ladies" came from someone else's choreography. We look at the legal side in Nobody Owns the Eight-Count You Took Off Instagram.

Why heels dancers should care

"Single Ladies" is one of the routines that made dancing in heels mainstream, and it led many people to their first heels class. Behind it are two lineages heels dancers still learn from: Fosse jazz for precision and isolation, and voguing for attitude and line, which we explore in What Is Voguing?.

If you want to understand why a heels choreography works, watch "Mexican Breakfast" and "Single Ladies" one after the other.

FAQ

Who choreographed 'Single Ladies'?

Frank Gatson Jr. and JaQuel Knight, working with Beyoncé. Knight was 19 at the time.

Did Beyoncé copy Bob Fosse?

The routine was openly inspired by 'Mexican Breakfast', a Bob Fosse number danced by Gwen Verdon on The Ed Sullivan Show in 1969. Gatson and Beyoncé have both acknowledged the reference.

What does this have to do with heels dance?

'Single Ladies' is one of the routines that made choreography in heels mainstream, and Fosse's style of isolations, attitude and precise detail runs through heels classes today.

Sources

  1. Marie Claire, "There's Something You Don't Know About the 'Single Ladies' Video"
  2. The Daily Dot, on Beyoncé, 'Single Ladies' and 'Mexican Breakfast'
  3. Dance Teacher, "Bob Fosse: The Choreographer Who Changed Broadway Jazz"
  4. The Dance Enthusiast, Lisa Jo Sagolla, on Sweet Gwen Suite
  5. NPR, "Chicago dance company adds Fosse work that inspired choreography to Beyoncé hit", 12 November 2024
ChoreographyJazzMusic videoHistory

Updated 18 November 2026