Nobody owns a basic dance step. In the United States, individual movements, social dance steps and simple routines cannot be copyrighted. Choreography can be protected when it forms an expressive whole, but the famous lawsuits over Fortnite dances never produced a ruling on that question. In practice, credit in the dance world is enforced by the community, not the courts.
What US law says
The US Copyright Office's Circular 52 states that individual movements or dance steps by themselves are not copyrightable, and that choreographic works do not include social dance steps and simple routines. That second idea goes back to the congressional report on the 1976 Copyright Act.
What can be protected is a choreographic work: a composition of movements with enough originality and coherence to count as authorship.
The Carlton and the Milly Rock
The Copyright Office has applied that rule to famous moves. In February 2019 it refused to register the Carlton, the dance from The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air, finding that its combination of three dance steps was a simple routine. It refused the Milly Rock as not forming an integrated, coherent and expressive compositional whole.
What the Fortnite cases really decided
Several dancers sued Epic Games after their moves appeared as Fortnite emotes. Those early cases were dropped, not lost on the merits. On 4 March 2019 the Supreme Court ruled in Fourth Estate v. Wall-Street.com that a work must be registered before its owner can sue. Without registration, the suits could not continue.
Confusing registrability with infringement is the most common mistake in this debate.
The later case Hanagami v. Epic Games went further. On 1 November 2023 the Ninth Circuit allowed it to proceed, writing that reducing choreography to "poses" would be like reducing music to just "notes". What is protected is the selection and arrangement. The case was settled in February 2024, so there is still no final ruling on the merits.
When a teacher sued his students
A case dancers rarely hear about is Bikram v. Evolation (Ninth Circuit, 2015). A yoga teacher sued former students for teaching his sequence. He lost: the court found the sequence was an idea, process or system, not protectable expression. The lesson for dance teachers is uncomfortable. The law protects your students' freedom to use what you taught them.
Credit is a moral question
A study published in the Harvard Law Review (volume 138) argues that the real enforcement mechanism in the choreography community is normative, not legal: reputation, public credit, call-outs, and the expectation that you name your sources.
That matches what happens online. When a viral routine is taught without credit, the response comes in comments and stitches, not lawsuits. As we show in our article on TikTok and African music, credit for viral choreographers has improved in recent years; payment has not followed.
What to do as a teacher
- Credit the choreographer when you teach a routine, by name and handle.
- If you create choreography you want to protect, document it, publish it with your name and date, and consider registration where it is available.
- Do not pretend a social step is yours. The community remembers.
The eight-count you saw on Instagram is free to learn. Whether you say where you got it says more about you than about the law.
FAQ
Can you copyright a dance move?
In the United States, individual movements and social dance steps are not copyrightable. A choreographic work, an expressive arrangement of movements, can be.
Did dancers win the Fortnite emote lawsuits?
No. The early suits were dropped after a 2019 Supreme Court decision required copyright registration before suing. The later Hanagami case was settled in February 2024 without a ruling on the merits.
Should I credit the choreographer of a routine I teach?
Yes. Even when the law does not require it, credit is how the dance community recognises and sustains creators.
Sources
- U.S. Copyright Office, Circular 52, Copyright Registration of Choreography and Pantomime
- U.S. Copyright Office refusals for the Carlton (February 2019) and the Milly Rock
- Fourth Estate Public Benefit Corp. v. Wall-Street.com, U.S. Supreme Court, 4 March 2019
- Hanagami v. Epic Games, Ninth Circuit, 1 November 2023
- Bikram's Yoga College of India v. Evolation Yoga, Ninth Circuit, 2015
- Harvard Law Review, vol. 138, on choreography and community norms